There is a kind of Christian who can recite the Gospel with precision, lead a small group through Romans, weep at worship, and still be a complete stranger to themselves. I know this Christian. I have been this Christian. And if you are reading the opening pages of The Christian Jung and feeling something quiet move in you, the kind of stirring that does not announce itself, I suspect you have known this Christian too. This is not a piece about people on the edges of faith. This is a piece about the most devout among us. The serious ones. The ones who have read Bonhoeffer and prayed through the Psalms and given more of themselves than was wise. This is a piece about how a sincere love for Christ can run for decades alongside a profound, unspoken self-abandonment. And it is a piece about how that began to break open in me.
Where We Are in the Journey
We are building, week by week, a theology of wholeness serious enough for the soul’s hidden life. In this series, we are learning that discipleship is not only behavioral. It is psychological, spiritual, and embodied. Through contemplative Christianity, Scripture, and depth psychology, we are recovering the inner terrain where transformation actually begins. Episodes 1 and 2 named what lives below the surface of sincere faith. Episode 3 begins to name something harder. The way Christianity itself, as it is often practiced, can quietly make us strangers to our own souls.
A Holiness That Hides You from Yourself
The Christianity I inherited, and for many years preached, was very clear on emotions. Do not trust them. Do not follow them. Emotions are unreliable, fleshly, deceptive, and almost always the doorway to sin. If you felt something inconvenient, you prayed it away. If you felt something painful, you spiritualized it. If you felt something the sermon said you should not feel, you repented of the feeling itself. The mature Christian, I was taught, was the one whose inner life had been thoroughly disciplined into silence.
This is what I want to call hyper-spiritualization. It is the practice of turning every interior experience into a moral verdict before it can become an honest one. It treats the body as a temptation rather than a temple. It treats emotion as a threat rather than a signal. And it produces, slowly, a Christian who is impressively obedient on the outside and increasingly absent on the inside. The official word for the result is false self. Scripture has its own word for the work that creates it. Performance.
This is what Jesus rebuked in the religious leaders of His day. Not their theology. Their distance from themselves. “You hypocrites! Well did Isaiah prophesy of you, when he said: This people honors me with their lips, but their heart is far from me” (Matthew 15:7–8). The Greek word translated hypocrite in that passage is hypokritēs, the word for a stage actor. Jesus was not accusing them of lying about doctrine. He was naming the gap between the outer performance and the inner person. The lips were near. The heart was far. And the heart, in Scripture, is not the seat of sentiment. It is the seat of the whole hidden self, what Psalm 51:6 calls “truth in the inward being.”
A Christianity that punishes the inward being into silence does not produce holiness. It produces a beautifully behaved stranger.
Why This Damage Looks So Much Like Maturity
The reason this is so difficult to see is that the false self often looks more spiritual than the true self does. The false self does not skip church. The false self does not argue with leaders. The false self volunteers, serves, smiles, and never causes problems. The false self can preach. I know, because I did. For years.
What the false self cannot do is bring the actual person to God. It can only bring the curated version. And the curated version, however reverent it sounds, cannot be sanctified, because it does not exist. You cannot heal what is not present. You cannot transform what has been replaced. Christ did not die for the version of you that survives by hiding. He died for the one underneath.
Personal Story
Like many of you, I grew up with a Christianity that severely punished emotions. Still to this day, there are preachers who will tell you that your emotions are dangerous, that they will lead you to sin, that they cannot have a voice in your spirituality. And I want you to know something. I was one of those preachers for a long time.
This is profoundly damaging. But for me, it was also deeply convenient. I was born with Cerebral Palsy. I grew up inside a body that did not move the way I wanted it to, that drew attention I did not want, that produced griefs I had no framework to process. The idea of eliminating my emotions did not sound like spiritual death to me. It sounded like rescue. The Christianity I was inside agreed. My emotions, especially the ones tied to my body and my disability, were dangerous places. They were full of questions I could not answer and pain I could not metabolize. So I learned to cut them off. And the culture around me applauded that decision as maturity.
After thirty years of suppressing my emotions, I had cut off my body too. I told myself I had done what I was supposed to do. Just be Spirit. Not soul. Not body. Holy in a way that required no embodied presence. Devout in a way that required no actual self. And I believed this was the shape of a serious Christian life.
It was not. It was a slow, sanctioned disappearance.
What changed me was not a better sermon. It was God beginning a long, patient process of teaching me about my emotions and my body, mostly through the language of Jungian psychology, a language the church had told me to fear and which the Lord used to bring me home to my own soul. I am still learning this. Slowly. So that the foundation is secure. Because an emotionally healed, whole, full-bodied human being is a beautiful thing to bring to God for His use. And so, by His mercy, is the broken, unassimilated, sometimes brutal emotional self that you may be carrying right now. All of it. All of it becomes part of sanctification and wholeness in Christ.
What Jung Saw, That Scripture Already Knew
Jung had a name for the part of us we exile in order to be acceptable. He called it the shadow. It is not the same as sin, though Christians often hear it that way and recoil. The shadow is everything about ourselves that we have decided we are not allowed to be. The grief. The anger. The desire. The hunger. The doubt. The body. The longing. The parts we have ruled inadmissible to consciousness, often because someone we trusted, a parent, a pastor, a culture, told us they were inadmissible to God. In Memories, Dreams, Reflections, Jung describes his own slow recognition that the personality he had been performing was not the whole of him, and that what he called his No. 2 personality, the deeper inner self, had been speaking to him through dreams and images for years.
Scripture said this first, and said it more honestly. “Search me, O God, and know my heart. Try me, and know my anxious thoughts. See if there is any grievous way in me, and lead me in the way everlasting” (Psalm 139:23–24). The Psalmist is not asking God to inspect the part he can already see. He is asking God into the part he cannot. The unsearched parts. The places that even he does not yet know. The Hebrew word for heart in that passage, lev, includes thought, will, emotion, body, and the depths of the inward life. David is not asking God to evaluate his behavior. He is asking God to enter his interior, including the rooms he himself has never opened.
This is the work the Pharisees would not allow. It is the work many of us were taught was unsafe.
Something Has Been Trying to Reach You
If you have read this far, something in you already knows. The exhaustion you carry is not because you have not tried hard enough. The dullness in your worship is not because you need to repent more. The flatness in your prayer life is not because your theology is wrong. Your soul is not asking for stricter management. It is asking for return.
And here is what most articles will not tell you. Naming this pattern is not the same as knowing what to do with it. Recognition without a path is its own kind of grief.
• • •
Inside The Inner Room This Week
There is something I have not said yet, and it is the most important thing.
You can see the false self clearly, understand exactly how your Christianity became a system for managing your inner life rather than healing it, and still not know how to take a single step toward the thing underneath. Insight does not heal. Insight only locates.
In The Inner Room this week, I am going to walk you through the practice I return to every time I realize I have left myself again. It comes from the Desert Fathers, and it has a name. Watchfulness, what they called nepsis. The attentive, gentle, non-condemning observation of what is actually moving inside you. Not analysis. Not judgment. Not more spiritual performance. Something much quieter than that.
I am also going to give you the specific question I ask myself when I cannot feel anything, the one that has never failed to locate something real. And I am going to show you how to bring what you find directly into prayer, so that the hidden self is not examined in isolation but held by Christ Himself.
The first practice begins with your body, because that is where thirty years of suppression actually live. And I want to show you the smallest possible doorway in, because doorways into the body cannot be forced. They have to be entered slowly, the way you enter a sanctuary.
• • •
Subscribe Covenant
If you are here, you are not looking for inspiration. You are looking for the kind of Christian formation that takes the soul seriously and does not flinch when the work goes deep. The Christian Jung is a slow, weekly walk into psychological wholeness held inside orthodox faith. Free readers receive the public arc each Sunday. Inner Room members receive the deeper teaching, the contemplative practices, and the formation work that turns recognition into healing. Join us today.
Heal Deeply. Walk Holy.
What a powerful article! Thank you for sharing 💛I grew up in Fundamentalism and recognize these high-control tactics all too well. Keep up the great work!